Oct 23, 2010 © Ulrich Theobald
Shuoyuan 說苑 "Garden of persuasions" is a collection of short stories of persons from antiquity to the Former Han period 前漢 (206 BCE-8 CE). It was compiled by the imperial librarian Liu Xiang 劉向 (79-8 or 77-6 BCE). The original title of the book was Xinyuan 新苑 "New garden", and it contained 748 stories arranged in 20 chapters.
The stories centre on Confucian scholars and other persons belonging to philosophical schools or political advisors. They are arranged according to the theme of discussion, from the relationship between ruler and minister, estimating worthies and competent counsellors, to plans for strengthening the state and government or how to conquer inimical territory. The largest part of the stories are dialogues between an advisor and a ruler. Many of them are also preserved in other books, like the Guoyu 國語 and Zhanguoce 戰國策, but there are also some stories not to be found there. 16 stories date from the Han period, all others from the Warring States period 戰國 (5th cent-221 BCE).
The book was originally and is still classified as a Confucian treatise, but Liu Xie 劉勰 (c. 465-522) from the Southern Dynasties period 南朝 (420~589), author of the literary critique Wenxin diaolong 文心雕龍, interpreted the stories as of more literary character. The Shuoyuan was, therefore, in later ages often classified as a collection of short stories, ins spite of its rather historiographical content.
The stories were so famous that authors of later ages regularly quoted from the Shuoyuan. The imperial bibliography Jingjizhi 經籍志 of the official dynastic history Suishu 隋書 speaks of a length of 20 juan, while the bibliographical chapters in the two history books Jiutangshu 舊唐書 and Xintangshu 新唐書 indicate at a content of 30 chapters (if juan and chapter are corresponding). The last version might include the 10-juan long supplement Xu Shuoyuan 續說苑, which was written by Liu Kuang 劉貺 (early 8th cent.) during the Tang period 唐 (618-907).
The original version was already lost during the Song period 宋 (960-1279), but the scholar Zeng Gong 曾鞏 (1019-1083) reconstructed most of the missing parts based on quotations in other books. His reconstruction is 20-juan long and includes 678 stories. This is the received version.
The Shuoyuan is included in the series Han-Wei congshu 漢魏叢書, Siku quanshu 四庫全書, Baizi quanshu 百子全書, Sibu congkan 四部叢刊, Congshu jicheng 叢書集成 and Sibu beiyao 四部備要. The edition in the Sibu congkan was reprinted by the Shanghai guji chubanshe 上海古籍出版社 in 1990. There are modern commentaries compiled by Zhao Shanyi 趙善詒 (Shuoyuan shuzheng 說苑疏證) and by Liu Wendian 劉文典 (Shuoyuan jiaobu 說苑斠補).
There is a complete translation by Eric Henry. 2022. Garden of Eloquence / Shuoyuan 說苑. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Table 1. Contents of the Shuoyuan 說苑
1. |
君道 |
Jundao |
The way of the ruler |
2. |
臣術 |
Chenshu |
The craft of ministers |
3. |
建本 |
Jianben |
Building the roots |
4. |
立節 |
Lijie |
Establishing integrity |
5. |
貴德 |
Guide |
Esteeming virtue |
6. |
復恩 |
Fuen |
Repaying favours |
7. |
政理 |
Zhengli |
The principles of government |
8. |
尊賢 |
Zunxian |
Honouring the worthies |
9. |
正諫 |
Zhengjian |
Upright remonstrance |
10. |
敬慎 |
Jingshen |
Diligent prudence |
11. |
善說 |
Shanshuo |
Skill in argument |
12. |
奉使 |
Fengshi |
The performance of missions |
13. |
權謀 |
Quanmou |
Judgment and strategy |
14. |
至公 |
Zhigong |
Impartiality |
15. |
指武 |
Zhiwu |
Military affairs |
16. |
談叢 |
Tancong |
Aphorisms |
17. |
雜言 |
Zayan |
Miscellaneous discourses |
18. |
辨物 |
Bianwu |
Discrimination of issues |
19. |
脩文 |
Youwen |
The cultivation of civil order |
20. |
反質 |
Fanzhi |
Returning to the essence |
Sources:
Gao Limei 高立梅. 2008. "Shuoyuan ru-fa jiehe de dexing guan 《說苑》儒法結合的德刑觀." Xiangtan Shifan Xueyuan xuebao (Shehui kexue ban) 湘潭師範學院學報(社會科學版) 2008 (4): 19-21.
Gao Yue 高月. 2013. "Liu Xiang Shuoyuan yanjiu zonglun 劉向《說苑》研究綜論." Hunan shehui kexue 湖南社會科學 2013 (2): 206-209.
Huang Zhenyun 黃震雲. 2006. "Qianfulun, Shuoyuan Zhong shenhua de lishihua yu chenweihua 《潛夫論》《說苑》中神話的歷史化與讖緯化." Nandu xuetan 南都學壇 2006 (1): 74-77.
Jia Dongyue 賈冬月. 2006. "Liu Xiang Xinxu, Shuoyuan, Lienüzhuan de xiaoshuo tezheng 劉向《新序》《說苑》《列女傳》的小說特徵." Suihua Xueyuan xuebao 綏化學院學報 2006 (6): 66-69.
Jiang Zhongmu 蔣重母, and Xie Xiangjuan 謝祥娟. 2012. "Lun Liu Xiang Shuoyuan de rujia lunli sixiang 論劉向《說苑》的儒家倫理思想." Mingzuo xinshang 名作欣賞 2012 (2): 72-74.
Knechtges, David R. 1993. "Shuo yüan." In Early Chinese Texts: A Bibliographical Guide, edited by Michael Loewe, 443-445. Berkeley: Society for the Study of Early China/Institute of East Asian Studies.
Li Cuiye 李翠葉. 2014. "Han-chu de wenhua wengzhe yu Shuoyuan zaji de wenti gongneng 漢初的文化整合與《說苑》雜記的文體功能." Wenyi pinglun 文藝評論 2014 (6): 88-92.
Liu Wenbin 劉文斌. 2013. "Zai lun Yanzi chunqiu de zhuzuo shuxing: Cong Lienüzhuan, Xinxu, Shuoyuan cailu cailiao de xingzhi shuo qi 再論《晏子春秋》的著作屬性——從《列女傳》《新序》《說苑》採錄材料的性質說起." Shenyang Shifan Daxue xuebao (Shehui kexue ban) 瀋陽師範大學學報(社會科學版) 37 (4): 123-126.
Liu Zhaoyun 劉兆雲. 1991. "Shuoyuan 說苑." In Zhongguo wenxue da cidian 中國文學大辭典, edited by Ma Liangchun 馬良春, and Li Futian 李福田, vol. 6, 4577. Tianjin: Tianjin renmin chubanshe.
Luo Qia 羅恰. 2011. "You Shuyuan yin Shi de Shang-bo jian Kongzi shilun zai kan Kongzi shixue 由《說苑》引《詩》和上博簡《孔子詩論》再看孔子詩學." Chang’an Daxue xuebao (Shehui kexue ban) 長安大學學報(社會科學版) 13 (3): 78-84.
Ma Zhenfang 馬振方. 2008. "Xinxu, Shuoyuan zhi xiaoshuo kaobian 《新序》、《說苑》之小說考辨." Wenyi yanjiu 文藝研究 2008 (4): 46-56.
Shen Huijuan 申慧娟. 2018. "Liu Xiang Xinxu, Shuoyuan, Lienüzhuan yanjiu zongshu 劉向《新序》《說苑》《列女傳》研究綜述." Ha'erbin Xueyuan xuebao 哈爾濱學院學報 39 (4): 88-92.
Stumpfeldt, Hans. 2011. Ein Garten der Sprüche: Das Shuo-yüan des Liu Hsiang (79–8 v. Chr.). Gossenberg: Ostasien Verlag.
Wang Huaping 王化平. 2011. "You Kongzi jiayu yu Liji, Shuoyuan zhushu de guanxi kan qi jiazhi 由《孔子家語》與《禮記》、《說苑》諸書的關係看其價值." Guji zhengli yanjiu xuekan 古籍整理研究學刊 2011 (1):1-7.
Wang Shouliang 王守亮. 2011. "Xinxu, Shuoyuan, Lienüzhuan wie Liu Xiang bianzhuan: Jian tan Liu Xiang san shu de xiaoshuo shi jiazhi 《新序》、《說苑》、《列女傳》為劉向編撰——兼談劉向三書的小說史價值." Zhejiang Haiyang Xueyuan xuebao (Renwen kexue ban) 浙江海洋學院學報(人文科學版) 28 (3): 12-14+25.
Xia Dekao 夏德靠. 2018. "Lun Shuoyuan, Xinxu de bianzhuan ji qi wenti tezheng 論《說苑》《新序》的編撰及其文體特徵." Zhonghua wenhua luntan 中華文化論壇 2018 (5): 66-77.
Xing Peishun 邢培順. 2004. "Liu Xiang Xinxu, Shuoyuan, Lienüzhuan cailiao laiyuan ji jiagong qushe fangshi tansuo 劉向《新序》《說苑》《列女傳》材料來源及加工取舍方式探索." Binzhou Shizhuan xuebao 濱州師專學報 2004 (1): 11-15.
Xu Jianwei 徐建委. 2008. "Liu Xiang Shuoyuan banben yuanliu kao 劉向《說苑》版本源流考." Wenxian 文獻 2008 (2):58-69.
Yang Bo 楊波. 2007a. "Lun Shuoyuan, Xinyu tongti cailiao de yunyong 論《說苑》、《新序》同題材料的運用." Guji zhengli yanjiu xuekan 古籍整理研究學刊 2007 (4): 83-86.
Yang Bo 楊波. 2007b. "Xinxu, Shuoyuan yu Hanshi waizhuan tongti yizhi gushi bijiao 《新序》、《說苑》與《韓詩外傳》同題異旨故事比較." Lanzhou xuekan 蘭州學刊 2007 (12): 126-129.
Yao Juan 姚娟. 2008. "Xinxu, Shuoyuan wenxian yanjiu zongshu 《新序》《說苑》文獻研究綜述." Fuyang Shifan Xueyuan xuebao (Shehui kexue ban) 阜陽師範學院學報(社會科學版) 2008(02):18-21.
Yu Da 俞達, and Xie Kefeng 謝科峰. 2014. "Xiaoyi gushu chengshu de mou xie xianxiang: Yi Shuoyuan, Kongzi jiayu hujian neirong zhong guanyu Kongzi jizai de chayi wei zhongxin 小議古書成書的某些現象——以《說苑》、《孔子家語》互見內容中關於孔子記載的差異為中心." Guji zhengli yanjiu xuekan 古籍整理研究學刊 2014 (2): 19-23.
Zhao Hankun 趙含坤. 2005. Zhongguo leishu 中國類書, 22. Shijiazhuang: Hebei renmin chubanshe.